• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Useful Ideas Project

Useful Ideas Project

Frances Ha, Modern Love & The Commercialization of Dissent

July 23, 2014 By Useful Ideas Project Leave a Comment

Frances Halladay, in pursuit of Ha Ha happiness
Frances Halladay, in pursuit of Ha Ha happiness

Frances Halladay is dancing down Catherine Street in New York, her body moving in time to David Bowie’s Modern Love:

Bowie sings:

Modern love – walks beside me
Modern love – walks on by
Modern love – gets me to the church on time
Church on time – terrifies me
Church on time – makes me party
Church on time – puts my trust in god and man
God and man – no confessions
God and man – no religion
God and man – don’t believe in modern love

Even though a new love or perhaps meaning may be around the corner, she runs out of street too quickly. Back at the shared apartment, she flops down and reads 1993’s ‘The American Nonconformist in the Age of the Commercialization of Dissent’, from The Baffler archives that opened today. It begins:

“Thirty-five years ago, Norman Mailer first gave voice to the idea that the “hipster,” the young art-appreciating free-spirit alienated from an increasingly repressive society, was the existential hero of the day. In an America terrified by the bomb, grown stagnant from over-organization, cowed into homogeneity and conformity by red scares and the depersonalization of the computer age, the “hipster” was supposed to represent liberty and the affirmation of life.

“The only life-giving answer” to the deathly drag of American civilization, Mailer wrote, was to tear oneself from the security of physical and spiritual certainty, to embrace rebellion, particularly rebellion associated with the subculture of jazz and drugs. The distinction between those who resisted mass society and those who collaborated was a clear and obvious one, Mailer insisted: “one is Hip or one is Square . . . one is a rebel or one conforms . . . trapped in the totalitarian tissues of American society, doomed willy-nilly to conform if one is to succeed.””

See also

Review: The Men Who Made Us Spend.

Links

Frances Ha review

Filed Under: Arts, Culture, Features, Film Tagged With: Frances Ha, Frances Ha David Bowie Modern Love, Greta Gerwig, Greta Gerwig David Bowie, Home, The Baffler

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe for more useful ideas

Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new ideas by email.

Recent Posts

  • Daniel Hannan. Who is he? Who funds him and what do they want?
  • Brexit and carelessness
  • Flooding the zone
  • Brexit, empire and cultural dementia. David Andress demolishes lazy nationalism
  • Brexit explained in three tweets

Pages

  • About
  • All posts
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Useful ideas list
  • Why Brexit happened

Search this website

Recent Comments

  • Julian Hill on James Joyce in summary: escape is a key theme in his work
  • loopyhoop on Brexit, empire and cultural dementia. David Andress demolishes lazy nationalism
  • Extrageographic on Boris Johnson and fake Brexit nationalism
  • Turth on Reasons why Brexit is not valid
  • Turth on Boris Johnson and fake Brexit nationalism

Copyright © 2021 Useful Ideas Project